U.S. Airlines Avoid Major Impact From Airbus ELAC Issue
Since my son is an Airbus captain and as a private pilot myself, I was happy to see that U.S. airlines appear to have avoided major disruptions after the FAA required emergency modifications to about 545 Airbus A319, A320, and A321 models.
Airbus recently announced stated that after an A320 altitude-loss event in October, a preliminary analysis had found that “intense solar radiation” may have caused a malfunction of the aircraft’s elevator aileron computer (ELAC) system, which uses pilot commands to control elevators and ailerons. That prompted the European Union Aviation Safety Agency (EASA) and FAA to issue emergency airworthiness directives (EADs) grounding certain A319, A320, and A321 models until carriers completed ELAC modifications.
On December 1, Airbus said that out of about 6,000 potentially affected aircraft, less than 100 are still awaiting modifications before returning to service. American Airlines and Delta Air Lines told FLYING they have met all requirements in the FAA’s EAD.
“Airbus apologizes for any challenges and delays caused to passengers and airlines by this event,” the manufacturer said Monday.
A few hours later, however, Reuters reported that Airbus identified a separate issue related to the quality of A320-family metal panels. The company blamed the problem on an unnamed partner. A320 components and parts are sourced from thousands of internal and external suppliers.
“Airbus confirms it has identified a quality issue affecting a limited number of A320 metal panels,” the manufacturer told Reuters. “The source of the issue has been identified, contained and all newly produced panels conform to all requirements.”
During the cruise portion of a trip from Cancún, Mexico, to Newark, New Jersey, the Airbus A320 operating JetBlue Flight 1230 on October 30 suddenly pitched downward without pilot input.
Though the investigation is ongoing, Airbus identified the ELAC as a possible factor. Regulators determined the issue could impact other aircraft.
In response to the company’s alert operators transmission (AOT), EASA on Friday issued an EAD covering the A319, A320, and A321 families, requiring operators to install “serviceable” ELACs and prohibiting future installations of the affected system on new aircraft.
According to EASA, continuing operations with the faulty ELAC “could lead in the worst-case scenario to an uncommanded elevator movement that may result in exceeding the aircraft’s structural capability.”
The FAA in response issued its own EAD requiring U.S. operators of the affected models to comply with EASA’s directive by Sunday at 12:01 a.m. before further flight.
The EAD follows an FAA directive for major airlines to reduce operations during the federal government shutdown—which ended earlier this month—due to air traffic control (ATC) staffing issues. Limitations were swiftly lifted, though the FAA will reportedly probe airlines that did not comply with the order.
A320 and A321 aircraft comprise the bulk of JetBlue’s narrowbody fleet. It appears to have been hit harder than its competitors. Per an internal memo from chief operating officer Warren Christie, the airline as of Sunday afternoon still required modifications for 50 out of 150 affected aircraft, keeping them grounded.
Other airlines faced minimal disruptions.
American is among the world’s largest Airbus operators, with about 480 A320 family aircraft in its fleet. The carrier initially said 340 aircraft were affected, later revising that number down to 209. All American Airlines updates were completed recently, with no operational impacts since November 28.
Delta is another Airbus-heavy carrier. Per the airline’s latest SEC form 10-Q, it owns 59 A319s, 48 A320s, and 84 A321neos. It also operates 127 A321-200s, 50 of which are leased. The EAD affected about 50 A321neos.
United Airlines, which had six impacted aircraft, said on November 29 that only “minor disruption to a few flights” is anticipated. Allegiant Airlines, which operates a majority-Airbus fleet of A319s and A320s, similarly said only a handful of aircraft were affected and that there would be “minimal to no impact on our operations or customers’ travel plans.”
Frontier Airlines, one of America’s largest A320 operators reported that it successfully modified 144 impacted aircraft over last weekend, with no cancellations due to the ELAC update.